As always: we're Nu Skin affiliates and earn a commission if you buy through our link. And as always, we're going to tell you the things a commission normally buys silence about.
SmartWin is sold as the opening move of the TRMe programme — the product that gets you a fast, visible result in the first two weeks so you stay motivated. Nu Skin's own words: "Kickstart your weight wellness journey & help set your body up for a quick, healthy win during your initial weight management efforts."
There are two claims tangled together there, and they need separating. One is about what's in the capsules. The other is about what a "kickstart" even is. The second one is the interesting one, and nobody ever audits it.
First, What's Actually In It
Prickly pear cactus fruit · Moringa (drumstick leaf) · Curry leaf · Turmeric. Take three capsules twice daily with a meal — six capsules a day.
Doses published: none.
Now compare that to Slim-S:
| | Slim-S | SmartWin | |---|---|---| | Moringa | ✅ | ✅ | | Curry leaf | ✅ | ✅ | | Turmeric | ✅ | ✅ | | Prickly pear | — | ✅ | | Capsules/day | 2 | 6 | | Doses published | ❌ | ❌ |
Three of the four botanicals are identical. SmartWin is, as far as anyone outside Nu Skin can tell, Slim-S plus prickly pear, at triple the capsule count.
That is worth knowing before someone sells you both as a complementary pair. You may well be paying twice for the same three plants.
The Shared Base: There Is Real Evidence, With Real Problems
Those three shared botanicals — moringa, curry leaf, turmeric — are a patented complex (Slendacor / LI85008F), and there is a genuine randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial on it: Dixit et al., Diabetes, Obesity and Metabolism, 2018. 900 mg/day, two divided doses, 16 weeks, 5.36 kg lost versus 0.87 kg on placebo.
We took that trial apart in detail in our Slim-S review, and the short version is: the effect is implausibly large, the placebo arm barely moved over four months, a manufacturer-affiliated author was involved, and nobody independent has replicated it.
One thing does go in SmartWin's favour, though, and we'll give it credit. The trial dosed the complex in two divided doses per day. SmartWin is taken twice daily — which actually matches the studied protocol, where Slim-S (once daily) does not. If any TRMe product is delivering that complex the way the trial delivered it, the schedule points at this one.
But we still don't know the milligrams. And without the number, the trial cannot be attached to the capsule. That's criterion 03 again, and it is not a technicality — it's the difference between "there's research behind this" and "there's research behind an ingredient that may or may not be in here in a meaningful amount."
The New Ingredient: Prickly Pear
The one thing SmartWin adds is prickly pear cactus fruit (Opuntia ficus-indica). The marketing logic is fibre — the idea that it binds dietary fat in the gut and reduces absorption.
Pooled across randomised clinical trials, prickly pear produced a non-significant difference in body weight versus control: mean difference −0.83 kg, 95% CI −2.49 to 0.83. The confidence interval crosses zero — meaning the data are entirely compatible with no effect at all. Reductions in body-fat percentage, blood pressure and total cholesterol were observed; body weight did not reliably move.
So the ingredient that distinguishes SmartWin from Slim-S is the one whose meta-analysis says it doesn't reliably shift body weight. Small trials do show it increases faecal fat excretion — the mechanism is real in the sense that it does something — but that mechanism has not translated into weight loss in the pooled human data.
Now the Part Nobody Audits: What Is a "Kickstart"?
Here's the claim that actually sells this product: you'll see a quick win in the first two weeks.
And you probably will. That's the problem.
When anyone starts a reduced-calorie diet, three things happen in the first fortnight that have nothing to do with any capsule:
Glycogen and water. Cutting carbohydrate depletes muscle and liver glycogen, and every gram of glycogen is stored with roughly 3 grams of water. Losing a few hundred grams of glycogen drags a couple of kilos of water out with it. On the scale, in week one, that looks spectacular. It is not fat.
Gut contents. Eating less food — and often more fibre — changes what's physically sitting in your digestive tract. Also weighs something. Also not fat.
Genuine early fat loss. A real deficit does start burning fat immediately. This part is real. It's just far slower and less dramatic than the number on the scale in week one suggests.
We could find no evidence that any ingredient in SmartWin creates a distinct "kickstart" mechanism, and Nu Skin doesn't cite one either. The product's own trial evidence (such as it is) is the 16-week Slendacor study — which is not a two-week study at all.
And this is the same trap we keep running into across this whole industry, and the one we wrote about in Messi's nutritionist: a real result, credited to the wrong mechanism. You start eating less. You lose 2 kg in a fortnight. You were also taking SmartWin. The capsules get the credit. The deficit did the work.
The Honest Verdict
In its favour: the shared three-botanical base does correspond to a complex with a genuine double-blind trial, and SmartWin's twice-daily schedule actually matches that trial's dosing protocol — which is more than Slim-S can say.
Against it, and it's a lot:
- No doses published, so the trial can't be connected to the capsule. Criterion 03 failure.
- Prickly pear, the one ingredient that makes it different, has a meta-analysis showing no significant effect on body weight.
- Three-quarters of the formula duplicates Slim-S. Buying both may mean paying twice for the same plants.
- Six capsules a day is a real daily commitment for a blend with no product-specific trial.
- The "2-week kickstart" describes a calorie deficit, not a supplement effect. You'd get that fortnight whether or not you bought this.
What we'd tell a friend: if you want to try the botanical complex, SmartWin at least dose-schedules it like the trial did. But go in knowing you're paying for an early win that the diet was always going to give you — and that if you're also taking Slim-S, you're likely doubling up on three of the same ingredients.
And if you want the one product in this range whose dose is actually printed on the label, it remains MyEdge. It's a smaller promise, honestly kept.
See our full SmartWin breakdown →
Grab the free Label Decoder → — so the next time something promises you a "kickstart", you'll know exactly which question to ask.
We are Nu Skin affiliates and earn a commission on purchases through our links, at no extra cost to you. We publish the limitations of every product we recommend, including the ones we're paid on. Educational information about evidence only — not medical advice, and not a claim to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Turmeric can interact with blood-thinning medication. If you take any medication, are pregnant or breastfeeding, or manage a health condition, speak to your GP or pharmacist before starting this or any supplement.
Looking for supplements that meet this standard?
Every product we recommend has been evaluated against our 6-criteria science filter — clinical evidence, doses, certifications, and more.
See our recommended products